Biden trustbusters get free rein to accessorize
The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are his own.
By Jonathan Guilford
NEW YORK, Oct 25 (Reuters Breakingviews) -U.S. trustbuster Lina Khan’s biggest victory hasn’t come in David vs. Goliath challenges against the likes of Amazon.com AMZN.O. Instead, it might be Thursday’s court win against the acquisition of Michael Kors owner Capri CPRI.N by Kate Spade owner Tapestry TPR.N, which lopped $2 billion off the seller’s shares. While the deal is relatively small, the heft it adds to the Biden administration’s antitrust crusade might be enormous.
Judge Jennifer Rochon’s 163-page opinion backs the Khan-led Federal Trade Commission’s request to halt the $8.5 billion tie-up. The agency’s lawsuit argued that, despite the vast proliferation of handbag brands, Tapestry and Capri dominate a category dubbed “affordable luxury.” It might seem a stretch: the definition relies on specific materials and the bags’ Asian manufacturing provenance. Hedge funds didn’t quite buy it - target Capri’s shares rose steadily heading into closing arguments.
Khan has taken lumps for losing cases on far-flung theories before. Merger hawks argue that shots on goal matter: despite failing to stop, say, Facebook owner Meta Platforms META.O from acquiring virtual reality startup Within, a lawsuit can nudge the way judges think about deals even in a losing opinion, building to later victories. And Biden’s trustbusters need judges on-side, having proposed shake-ups in merger review that require the courts’ endorsement to stick.
That’s what makes Judge Rochon’s opinion so important. Indeed, she approvingly cited cases - like Meta/Within - that the FTC lost, as offering support. More importantly, she implicitly backed one of the biggest proposed overhauls in how deals are adjudicated.
Ordinarily, companies and the government bicker over defining a “relevant market”, such as a sub-slice of the economy, like “affordable luxury”, and proceed with their analysis from there. Failing to narrow this definition enough can stymie a lawsuit. Though the FTC also followed this traditional method, it argued that the deal is illegal regardless, since Capri and Tapestry are direct competitors that provably respond to each other’s pricing.
Rochon effectively endorsed this head-to-head analysis. Not only that, she agreed that Tapestry and Capri’s troves of consumer data hobbles less-endowed competitors, a decision with implications for technology deals. A bevy of other new merger guidelines earned judicial nods.
The only consolation for M&A bankers everywhere is that the victory was so comprehensive that Rochon didn’t even weigh in on more radical arguments, such as mergers harming the labor market by consolidating employers. The two companies said they have appealed the decision, so the trustbuster’s victory isn’t final. Nonetheless, Khan stands to make one of her biggest marks yet. Competition cops are getting more license to try on aggressive, merger-hostile arguments.
Follow @JMAGuilford on X
CONTEXT NEWS
Judge Jennifer Rochon of the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York on Oct. 24 issued a preliminary injunction blocking the acquisition of handbag maker Capri by rival Tapestry.
The Federal Trade Commission had sued to block the tie-up, which would have united brands including Kate Spade and Michael Kors. Capri shares opened down 46% on Oct. 25.
Capri investors had been increasingly optimistic https://reut.rs/3AcGyv7
Editing by Robert Cyran and Pranav Kiran
免责声明: XM Group仅提供在线交易平台的执行服务和访问权限，并允许个人查看和/或使用网站或网站所提供的内容，但无意进行任何更改或扩展，也不会更改或扩展其服务和访问权限。所有访问和使用权限，将受下列条款与条例约束：(i) 条款与条例；(ii) 风险提示；以及(iii) 完整免责声明。请注意，网站所提供的所有讯息，仅限一般资讯用途。此外，XM所有在线交易平台的内容并不构成，也不能被用于任何未经授权的金融市场交易邀约和/或邀请。金融市场交易对于您的投资资本含有重大风险。
所有在线交易平台所发布的资料，仅适用于教育/资讯类用途，不包含也不应被视为用于金融、投资税或交易相关咨询和建议，或是交易价格纪录，或是任何金融商品或非应邀途径的金融相关优惠的交易邀约或邀请。
本网站上由XM和第三方供应商所提供的所有内容，包括意见、新闻、研究、分析、价格、其他资讯和第三方网站链接，皆保持不变，并作为一般市场评论所提供，而非投资性建议。所有在线交易平台所发布的资料，仅适用于教育/资讯类用途，不包含也不应被视为适用于金融、投资税或交易相关咨询和建议，或是交易价格纪录，或是任何金融商品或非应邀途径的金融相关优惠的交易邀约或邀请。请确保您已阅读并完全理解，XM非独立投资研究提示和风险提示相关资讯，更多详情请点击 这里。
